Suggestions by @floydylan
25 suggestions

Paul Dano
as The Riddler in The Batman: Arkham Asylum (2019)

Jeffrey Wright
as Commissioner James Gordon in The Batman: Arkham Asylum (2019)

Barry Keoghan
as The Joker in The Batman: Arkham Asylum (2019)
Robert Pattinson
as The Batman in The Batman: Arkham Asylum (2019)

Phil Collins
as Mr. Freeze in Batman Characters but only cast musicians
David Bowie
as Riddler in Batman Characters but only cast musicians
Joe Walsh
as Scarecrow in Batman Characters but only cast musicians

David Lee Roth
as Joker in Batman Characters but only cast musicians

Joe Pesci
as Joe Barbaro in Per Aspera Ad Astra (1980)

Robert De Niro
as Vito Scaletta in Per Aspera Ad Astra (1980)

Martin Scorsese
as Director in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Lee Van Cleef
as Sergio Morello in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Bo Hopkins
as Lucas Bertone in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Robert Shaw
as Detective Norman in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Peter Boyle
as Vincenzo Ricci in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Cesare Danova
as Don Morello in Crème de la Crème (1974)

John Marley
as Luigi in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Frederic Forrest
as Vincenzo Ricci in Crème de la Crème (1974)

Brad Dourif
as Ralph in Crème de la Crème (1974)
Simonetta Stefanelli
as Sarah Angelo in Crème de la Crème (1974)