Suggestions by @ filmeinstein

Joaquin Phoenix

as Jack Torrance in The Shining

Pete Davidson

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

+1-2Score: -1

Dylan Minnette

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

+1-2Score: -1

Jaeden Martell

as Jim Levenstein in American Pie

Timothée Chalamet

as Jim Levenstein in American Pie

John Krasinski

as Mr. Levenstein in American Pie

Bill Hader

as Mr. Levenstein in American Pie

Heidi Gardner

as Stifler's Mom in American Pie

Naomi Scott

as Nadia in American Pie

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Linus/Minus in Sharkboy and Lavagirl remake

+1-3Score: -2

Richard Ayoade

as George Thomason in A Fish Called Wanda (2024)

Martin Freeman

as Archie Leach in A Fish Called Wanda (2024)

Brie Larson

as Wanda Gerschiwtz in A Fish Called Wanda (2024)

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Otto West in A Fish Called Wanda (2024)

Candi Milo

as Muriel Bagge in The New Adventures of Courage the Cowardly Dog (Netflix Original Series)

+3-1Score: +2

Marty Grabstein

as Courage the Cowardly Dog in The New Adventures of Courage the Cowardly Dog (Netflix Original Series)

Candi Milo

as Coco in Foster home For Imaginary Friends Movie Live Action

+2-0Score: +2

Madelaine Petsch

as Frankie foster in Foster home For Imaginary Friends Movie Live Action

Katherine McNamara

as Frankie foster in Foster home For Imaginary Friends Movie Live Action