Suggestions by @elijahvanderkwast
1,327 suggestions
Freya Skye
as Haley Dunphy in Modern Family Recast (2022)
Bella Ramsey
as Marlene McKinnon in Marauders (with British/UK/European Actors)
Bella Ramsey
as Marlene McKinnon in The Marauders
Florence Pugh
as Marlene McKinnon in All The Young Dudes
Lizzy Greene
as Marlene McKinnon (Young) in All The Young Dudes
Olivia Cooke
as Marlene McKinnon in The Marauders Era
Lizzy Greene
as Marlene McKinnon in All the Young Dudes
Aidan Turner
as Sirius Black in Maurauders Era
Harry Styles
as Sirius Black in Maurauders Era
Amybeth McNulty
as Lily Evans in All The Young Dudes
Amybeth McNulty
as Lily Evans in Fancasting the ATYD characters (feel free to add your own!)*
Amybeth McNulty
as Lily Evans in The Marauders Era
Emilia Jones
as Lily Evans in Marauders
Amybeth McNulty
as Lily Evans in Marauders
Hannah Dodd
as Lily Evans in All the Young Dudes
Leo Suter
as Eugene Fitzherbert in Tangled (Live Action)
John Stamos
as John in Celebrities With The Same Name
Michael C. Hall
as Michael in Celebrities With The Same Name
David Schwimmer
as David in Celebrities With The Same Name
Hailee Steinfeld
as Best Actress in Oscar Predictions (2026) + Awards