Suggestions by @elepstein

John Malkovich

as John Horatio Malkovich in The Player

Catherine Deneuve

as Catherine Muthekkiritennshi in The Player

James Mason

as "Chip" Chet Chunksky in The Player

Eli Wallach

as Warren Stufper in The Player

Elaine May

as Elaine May in The Player

Timothy Carey

as Timothy Carey in The Player

Stellan Skarsgård

as Stellan Skarsgård in The Player

John Turturro

as John Turturro in The Player

John Goodman

as John Goodman in The Player

Philip Baker Hall

as Philip Baker Hall in The Player

Jack Lemmon

as Jack Lemmon in The Player

Jean-Luc Godard

as Jean-Luc Godard in The Player

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Daniel Day-Lewis in The Player

William Holden

as William Holden in The Player

Paul Newman

as Paul Newman in The Player

Nick Nolte

as Nick Nolte in The Player

Marlon Brando

as Marlon Brando in The Player

Robert De Niro

as Robert DeNiro in The Player

Al Pacino

as Al Pacino in The Player

Jack Nicholson

as Jack Nicholson in The Player