Suggestions by @drewstar

Jeff Bridges

as Marshal Leigh Johnson in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

William H. Macy

as Seth Briars in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Brad Pitt

as Irish in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

W. Earl Brown

as Bill Williamson in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Ed Harris

as Landon Ricketts in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Viggo Mortensen

as John Marston in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Dustin Hoffman

as Nigel West Dickens in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Diego Luna

as Javier Escuella in Red Dead Redemption Part 1

Callan Mulvey

as Agent Archer Fordman in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Anne Hathaway

as Bonnie MacFarlane in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Juliette Lewis

as Abigail Marston in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Stephen Merchant

as Dr. Harold McDougall in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Bryan Cranston

as Dutch Van Der Linde in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Viggo Mortensen

as John Marston in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Seymour Cassel

as Agent Edger Ross in Red Dead Redemption Part 2

Stephen Merchant

as Harold MacDougal in Red Dead Redemption

Roger Clark

as Edgar Ross in Red Dead Redemption 2

Harron Atkins

as Lenny Summers in Red Dead Redemption 2

Noshir Dalal

as Charles Smith in Red Dead Redemption 2

Joel Coen

as Producer in Red Dead Redemption 2