Suggestions by @drewstar
617 suggestions

Hugh Bonneville
as Thurston Howell III in Gilligan's Island
John Goodman
as "Skipper" Jonas Grumby in Gilligan's Island

John Carpenter
as Director in Halloween (2018)

Robb Zombie
as Producer in Halloween (2018)
Tyler Mane
as Michael Myers in Halloween (2018)

Russell Harvard
as Kenneth in Salad Fingers
Lauren Potter
as Mable in Salad Fingers

John Carroll Lynch
as Dr. Papanak in Salad Fingers

Paul Bettany
as Kenneth in Salad Fingers

John C. Reilly
as Harry in Salad Fingers

Dustin Hoffman
as Hubert Cumberdale in Salad Fingers

Johnny Depp
as Salad Fingers in Salad Fingers
Taryn Manning
as Catwoman in Batman: The Graphic Stories

Armie Hammer
as Batman in Batman: The Graphic Stories

Iwan Rheon
as The Joker in Batman: The Graphic Stories

Karl Urban
as Joel in The Last of Us

Lex Shrapnel
as Count Julius in Berserk
Al Pacino
as The King of Midland in Berserk

Manny M. Hernandez
as Gaston in Berserk

Jacob Tremblay
as Rickert in Berserk