Suggestions by @daydreamer

Phil Collins

as God in The Bible

Stephen Tompkinson

as Abram / Abraham in The Bible

Arthur Darvill

as Simon / Peter in The Bible

Thomasin McKenzie

as Mary of Nazareth in The Bible

Millie Bobby Brown

as Mary of Nazareth in The Bible

Timothée Chalamet

as David in The Bible

Marwan Kenzari

as Jesus in The Bible

Hugh Laurie

as Pontius Pilate in The Bible

Jeff Goldblum

as God in The Bible

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Fear in Inside Out

Lexi Rabe

as Riley Anderson in Inside Out

Josh Gad

as Bing Bong in Inside Out

Arthur Darvill

as Kieran O'Lykos in Red Rising

Janina Gavankar

as Pocahontas in Disney Princesses

Christy Altomare

as Anya in Disney Princesses

Daniel Brühl

as Melkor in The Silmarillion

Keanu Reeves

as Morgarath in Ranger's Apprentice

Christy Altomare

as Glinda in Wicked (2021)

Anthony Daniels

as The Wizard in Wicked (2021)

Timothée Chalamet

as Alexandar au Arcos in Iron Gold