Suggestions by @dannyflanigan
1,039 suggestions
Bradley Freeman, Jr.
as Yorick in Midnight Muppets
Eric Jacobson
as Samuel in Midnight Muppets
Martin P. Robinson
as Snuffy in Midnight Muppets
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
as Abby Cadabby in Midnight Muppets
Eric Jacobson
as Oscar the Grouch in Midnight Muppets
Matt Vogel
as Calico in Midnight Muppets
David Rudman
as Jane Fiama in Midnight Muppets
Matt Vogel
as Crazy Harry in Midnight Muppets
Bradley Freeman, Jr.
as Elon Tusk in Midnight Muppets
Matt Vogel
as Arbez in Midnight Muppets
Eric Jacobson
as Daniel the Lion in Midnight Muppets
David Rudman
as Penguin in Midnight Muppets
David Rudman
as Annie Sue Pig in Midnight Muppets
Matt Vogel
as Spotted Dick in Midnight Muppets
Matt Vogel
as Old Tom in Midnight Muppets
Dave Goelz
as Sapphrost in Midnight Muppets
Bill Barretta
as Mama Fiama in Midnight Muppets
Ryan Dillon
as Elmo in Midnight Muppets
Ryan Dillon
as Clifford in Midnight Muppets
Eric Jacobson
as Grover in Midnight Muppets