Suggestions by @coolguy

Riz Ahmed

as Mister Zsasz in Every Batman Character

Michael Fassbender

as Joseph Christiansen in Dream Daddy: The Movie

Natalia Dyer

as Harlequin in Every Batman Character

Eliza Scanlen

as Harlequin in Every Batman Character

Aubrey Plaza

as Punchline in Every Batman Character

Alison Pill

as Peyton Riley in Every Batman Character

Karl Glusman

as Killer Moth in Every Batman Character

Stephen McKinley Henderson

as Professor Pyg in Every Batman Character

Kurt Russell

as Jim Gordon in Every Batman Character

Jackie Earle Haley

as Scarecrow in Every Batman Character

Sonoya Mizuno

as Catwoman in Every Batman Character

Charles Dance

as Alfred Pennyworth in Every Batman Character

Idris Elba

as Deadshot in Every Batman Character

Orlando Bloom

as Deadshot in Every Batman Character

Liev Schreiber

as Harvey Bullock in Every Batman Character

Evan Rachel Wood

as Poison Ivy in Every Batman Character

Russell Crowe

as Professor Pyg in Every Batman Character

Ralph Fiennes

as Professor Hugo Strange in Every Batman Character

Rami Malek

as Joker in Every Batman Character

Charlie Hunnam

as Catman in Every Batman Character