Suggestions by @coolguy

Natalie Portman

as The Phantasm in Every Batman Character

Brian Tyree Henry

as Killer Croc in Every Batman Character

Clancy Brown

as Harvey Bullock in Every Batman Character

Daniel Radcliffe

as Mad Hatter in Every Batman Character

Jeremy Strong

as Two-Face in Every Batman Character

Alison Brie

as Catwoman in Every Batman Character

Antonio Banderas

as Bane in Every Batman Character

Toni Collette

as Shauna Belzer in Every Batman Character

Jessie Buckley

as Batgirl in Every Batman Character

Christopher Abbott

as Ted Carson in Every Batman Character

Pete Davidson

as Condiment King in Every Batman Character

Ralph Ineson

as Scarecrow in Every Batman Character

Dakota Fanning

as Harley Quinn in Every Batman Character

Rooney Mara

as Jane Doe in Every Batman Character

Benedict Wong

as Professor Pyg in Every Batman Character

Tessa Thompson

as Catwoman in Every Batman Character

Rihanna

as Poison Ivy in Every Batman Character

Tim Roth

as Scarecrow in Every Batman Character

Timothy Olyphant

as Two-Face in Every Batman Character

Tom Ellis

as Black Mask in Every Batman Character