Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Enola Holmes

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Christine Canigula

as Kavi Sharma (2023) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Cosette

as Nellie O'Malley (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Ámbar Smith

as Mia St. Clair (2008) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Nancy Clancy

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Claudia (Interview with the Vampire)

as Claudie Wells (1922) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Misty

as Joss Kendrick (2020) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Serena (Pokemon)

as Grace Thomas (2015) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Mallow (Pokemon)

as Lea Clark (2016) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Webby Vanderquack (2017)

as Caroline Abbott (1812) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Christine Daaé

as Cécile Rey (1853) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Konata Izumi

as Courtney Moore (1986) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Sarah Williams

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Violetta Castillo

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Angelina Mouseling

as Isabelle Palmer (2014) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Karlach

as Addy Walker (1864) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Lucy van Pelt

as Samantha Parkington (1904) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Misty

as Kanani Akina (2011) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

Lois Lane

as Kit Kittredge (1934) in Fictional Characters by Which American Girl Doll They'd Have

The Trapper

as Cleaver Knife in Characters by Weapon of Choice