Suggestions by @connieblackwood

Maleficent

as Black Magic in Sort by Tropes

Into the Pit (Fazbear Frights)

as Newspaper Dating in Sort by Tropes

Five Nights at Freddy's: Into the Pit

as Newspaper Dating in Sort by Tropes

Oswald (FNaF)

as Newspaper Dating in Sort by Tropes

Atlantis (Disney)

as Sunken City in Sort by Tropes

Atlantis

as Sunken City in Sort by Tropes

The Houndmaster (Portia Maye)

as Bermuda Triangle in Sort by Tropes

The Sea of Monsters

as Bermuda Triangle in Sort by Tropes

Wednesday Addams

as Bermuda Triangle in Sort by Tropes

Roy Mustang

as Colonel Badass in Sort by Tropes

Zombies

as The Undead in Sort by Tropes

Carlton Burke

as You're Not My Type in Sort by Tropes

Oshawott

as Playful Otter in Sort by Tropes

Sealeo

as Sweet Seal in Sort by Tropes

Spheal

as Sweet Seal in Sort by Tropes

Dewgong

as Sweet Seal in Sort by Tropes

Seel

as Sweet Seal in Sort by Tropes

Rotor Walrus (Archie Comics)

as Warm-Hearted Walrus in Sort by Tropes

Rotor the Walrus

as Warm-Hearted Walrus in Sort by Tropes

Mila (The Music of the Dolphins)

as Friendly, Playful Dolphin in Sort by Tropes