Suggestions by @chris83

Billy Nolan

as Elvis Presley in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Danny Zuko

as Elvis Presley in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Betty Cooper (Archie Comics)

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Sabrina Spellman

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Cady Heron

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Winnie Carruthers

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Lisa Swallows

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Max Mayfield

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Eleanor (Do Revenge)

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Robin Buckley

as Shirley MacLaine in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Sherrie Christian

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Tracey Prescott

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Jade Butterfield (2014)

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Norma Watson

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Pam Miller

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Lisa Swallows

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Julia McDermitt

as Barbara Eden in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Maddie and Doug

as Couple Pairing Who Married or Dating Each Other in Real Life in Fictional Character Pairings

Maddie and Doug

as Lovers to Enemies in Fictional Character Pairings

Maddie and Doug

as Enemies in Fictional Character Pairings