Suggestions by @chesspiece99
5,432 suggestions

Michael Madsen
as Donny in Ted (1992)

Keanu Reeves
as John Bennett in Ted (1992)

Keith David
as Mr. Dark in The Rayman Movie

John Leguizamo
as Satan in Crucify This!

Ralph Fiennes
as Satan in Crucify This!

Mads Mikkelsen
as Satan in Crucify This!
Rodrigo Santoro
as Jesus Christ in Crucify This!

Willem Dafoe
as Satan in Crucify This!

Terry Crews
as Simon in Crucify This!

Jon Bernthal
as Thaddeus in Crucify This!

Ben Whishaw
as James of Alpheus in Crucify This!

Sam Claflin
as Bartholomew in Crucify This!

Hamish Linklater
as Philip in Crucify This!

Richard Madden
as Thomas in Crucify This!

Tom Hiddleston
as Matthew in Crucify This!

Dane DeHaan
as John in Crucify This!

Tom Hardy
as James in Crucify This!

Kit Harington
as Andrew in Crucify This!

Josh Brolin
as God in Crucify This!

Keith David
as God in Crucify This!