Suggestions by @chesspiece99

Keanu Reeves

as Frenchie in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Ralph Fiennes

as Edward "Ed" Teach in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Alan Rickman

as Edward "Ed" Teach in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Alan Rickman

as Izzy Hands in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

David Patrick Kelly

as The Swede in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Penélope Cruz

as Bonifacia "Jim" Jimenez in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

David Patrick Kelly

as Frenchie in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Tom Waits

as The Swede in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Brad Dourif

as Izzy in Our Flag Means Death (2002)

Gary Oldman

as Blackbeard in Our Flag Means Death (2002)

Tim Meadows

as Roach in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Robin Williams

as Stede Bonnet in Our Flag Means Death (2002)

Paul L. Smith

as Wee John in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Paul Bettany

as Lucius Spriggs in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Sean Bean

as Buttons in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Brad Dourif

as Izzy Hands in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Gary Oldman

as Edward "Ed" Teach in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Robin Williams

as Stede Bonnett in Our Flag Means Death (2002-2003)

Kumail Nanjiani

as Captain Nemo in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2024)

Paul L. Smith

as Chip Heron in David Lynch's Mean Girls (1994)