Suggestions by @charliesmith4

Odessa A'zion

as Nicki Flemming in American Girl: The Movie

Kiawentiio

as Kaya’aton’my’ in American Girl: The Movie

Glenna Walters

as Samantha Parkington in American Girl: The Movie

Mckenna Grace

as Kit Kittredge in American Girl: The Movie

Grace VanderWaal

as Kit Kittredge in American Girl: The Movie

Kyla Matthews

as Caroline Abbott in American Girl: The Movie

Dalila Bela

as Ruthie Smithens in American Girl: The Movie

Alyvia Alyn Lind

as Maryellen Larkin in American Girl: The Movie

Lennon Stella

as Tenney Grant in American Girl: The Movie

Taylor Swift

as Tenney Grant in American Girl: The Movie

Olivia Rodrigo

as Grace Thomas in American Girl: The Movie

Mackenzie Ziegler

as Isabella Palmer in American Girl: The Movie

Willow Shields

as Lanie Holland in American Girl: The Movie

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan

as Sonali Matthews in American Girl: The Movie

Momona Tamada

as Jess McConnell in American Girl: The Movie

Marsai Martin

as Melody Ellison in American Girl: The Movie

Sadie Sandler

as Lindsey Bergman in American Girl: The Movie

Emma Shannon

as Ruthie Smithens in American Girl: The Movie

Havana Rose Liu

as Ruthie Smithens in American Girl: The Movie

AnnaSophia Robb

as Samantha Parkington in American Girl: The Movie