Suggestions by @charlesp

Rose McIver

as Seras Victoria in Hellsing

Daniel Brühl

as Pip Bernadotte in Hellsing

Richard Armitage

as Lucifer in Paradise Lost

Stellan Skarsgård

as Lars Thorwald in Rear Window

Alice Eve

as Lisa Freemont in Rear Window

Patrick Wilson

as L.B. Jefferies in Rear Window

Doug Jones

as Vril Dox in DCEU Rebooted

Alice Eve

as Killer Frost in DCEU Rebooted

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Batman in The Batman (DCEU)

James McAvoy

as Foxy in Five Nights At Freddys

Scarlett Johansson

as Chica in Five Nights At Freddys

Jack Nicholson

as Phone Guy in Five Nights At Freddys

Anthony Hopkins

as Phone Guy in Five Nights At Freddys

Jon Bernthal

as Security guard in Five Nights At Freddys

Luke Goss

as Richard Staker in Salem's Lot

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Lucifer in Paradise Lost

Natalie Dormer

as Mary Ann Nichols in From Hell

Olivia Colman

as Annie Chapman in From Hell

Gemma Arterton

as Elizabeth Stride in From Hell

Sarah Bolger

as Mary Kelly in From Hell