Suggestions by @castingsinmyblood

Abraham Erskine

as James Doohan in What if this actor played

Abraham Erskine

as Peter Lorre in What if this actor played

The Beauty (TV series)

as Clayface in Which projects should inspire adaptations of these comics

Hugo Weaving

as Sarek in Star Trek (2014-2026)

Sarek

as Hugo Weaving in What if this actor played

Daniel Dravot (The Man Who Would Be King)

as Charlton Heston in What if this actor played

Apocalypse

as Arnold Vosloo in What if this actor played

Lois Lane

as May Hong in What if this actor played

Théoden

as John Schuck in What if this actor played

Count Orlok

as Christopher Walken in What if this actor played

Perry White

as Bill Smitrovich in What if this actor played

Abraham Van Helsing

as Tilda Swinton in What if this actor played

Jonathan Harker

as Ali Khan in What if this actor played

Mina Harker

as Lily Collins in What if this actor played

Arthur Holmwood

as William Moseley in What if this actor played

Lucy Westenra

as Holliday Grainger in What if this actor played

Dr. John Seward

as Daniel Kaluuya in What if this actor played

Quincey Morris

as Martin Sensmeier in What if this actor played

Jonathan Harker

as Dev Patel in What if this actor played

Odin Borson

as Ray Porter in What if this actor played