Suggestions by @caitlinfrost

Colin Firth

as Fitzwilliam Darcy in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Norm Lewis

as The Phantom of the Opera in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Oracle

as Nessarose Thropp in Wicked (if fictional characters made it)

Snips and Snails

as Ugly Cute in Sort by Tropes

Ralsei

as Doctor Dillamond in Wicked (if fictional characters made it)

Cornelius Fudge

as The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in Wicked (if fictional characters made it)

Charlotte La Bouff

as Glinda Upland in Wicked (if fictional characters made it)

Esmeralda

as Elphaba Thropp in Wicked (if fictional characters made it)

Amanda Seyfried

as Little Red Riding Hood in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Danielle Ferland

as Little Red Riding Hood in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Cassie Levy

as The Snow Queen in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Samantha Barks

as The Snow Queen in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Ciara Renée

as The Snow Queen in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

David Thewlis

as Hades in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Janet McTeer

as Hera in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Vanessa Redgrave

as Queen Guinevere in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

John Cleese

as Sir Lancelot in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Sam Neill

as Merlin in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Luke Evans

as Ebenezer Scrooge in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Kurt Russell

as Santa Claus in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters