Suggestions by @caitlinfrost
9,025 suggestions
Scourge (Warrior Cats)
as Depraved Dwarf in Sort by Tropes
Fantine (Les Miserables)
as Delicate and Sickly in Sort by Tropes
Ashfur (Warrior Cats)
as Deader than Dead in Sort by Tropes
Brokenstar (Warrior Cats)
as "Darkness von Gothick" Name in Sort by Tropes
Darkstripe (Warrior Cats)
as "Darkness von Gothick" Name in Sort by Tropes
Scourge (Warrior Cats)
as "Darkness von Gothick" Name in Sort by Tropes
White Widow (Mission: Impossible)
as Dark Action Girl in Sort by Tropes
White Widow (Mission: Impossible)
as Break the Haughty in Sort by Tropes
Gretchen Wieners
as Ambiguously Jewish in Sort by Tropes
White Widow (Mission: Impossible)
as All Girls Want Bad Boys in Sort by Tropes
White Widow (Mission: Impossible)
as Affably Evil in Sort by Tropes
If I Were A Rich Man
as Best Song in The MyCast Tonys
If I Were A Rich Man
as "I Want" Song in Sort by Tropes
Papillon
as Cosette in If Musical Characters were animals
Himalayan cat
as Christine Daae in If Musical Characters were animals
Vampire Bat
as Erik (The Phantom) in If Musical Characters were animals
Great Pyrenees
as Raoul in If Musical Characters were animals
Pitbull Terrier
as Jason "JD" Dean in If Musical Characters were animals
White Widow (Mission: Impossible)
as Caitlinfrost in myCast User's Favorite Characters
Sharpay Evans
as Diamond Tiara in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, if fictional characters made it