Suggestions by @caillansilver

Jessica Mauboy

as Erzulie in Once on this Island

Casey Donovan

as Papa Ge in Once on this Island

Stephanie Hsu

as Gussie Carnegie in Merrily We Roll Along

Pedro Pascal

as Professor Plum in Clue

Henry Golding

as Mr. Green in Clue

Adèle Exarchopoulos

as Yvette in Clue

Meryl Streep

as Mrs. Peacock in Clue

Zendaya

as Miss Scarlet in Clue

Jim Carrey

as Colonel Mustard in Clue

Mike Faist

as Wadsworth in Clue

Lola Tung

as Fate 2 in Hadestown

Daveed Diggs

as Hermes in Hadestown

Colman Domingo

as Hades in Hadestown

Roman Griffin Davis

as Jack in Into the woods

Ariana Greenblatt

as Little red in Into the woods

Jorja Smith

as Repunzel in Into the woods

Jordan Fisher

as Prince Charming in Into the woods

Corey Hawkins

as Repunzel’s Prince in Into the woods

Nicole Sherzinger

as The Witch in Into the woods

Phillipa Soo

as The bakers wife in Into the woods