Suggestions by @brianasalentine

Ralph Fiennes

as Garrett in Twilight

Ben Affleck

as Garrett in Twilight

Chris Pine

as Garrett in Twilight

Oscar Isaac

as Garrett in Twilight

Richard Madden

as Garrett in Twilight

Michael Fassbender

as Garrett in Twilight

Ryan Gosling

as Garrett in Twilight

Luke Evans

as Garrett in Twilight

Neil Patrick Harris

as Garrett in Twilight

John Krasinski

as Garrett in Twilight

Brenton Thwaites

as Garrett in Twilight

Chris Pratt

as Garrett in Twilight

Jon Hamm

as Garrett in Twilight

Bill Hader

as Garrett in Twilight

Timothée Chalamet

as Garrett in Twilight

Chris Evans

as Garrett in Twilight

Henry Cavill

as Garrett in Twilight

Keanu Reeves

as Garrett in Twilight

Dacre Montgomery

as Garrett in Twilight

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Garrett in Twilight