Suggestions by @brianasalentine

Joe Keery

as Caius in Twilight

Timothée Chalamet

as Caius in Twilight

Tom Holland

as Caius in Twilight

Logan Lerman

as Caius in Twilight

Liam Hemsworth

as Caius in Twilight

Ansel Elgort

as Caius in Twilight

Ronen Rubinstein

as Caius in Twilight

Dylan O'Brien

as Caius in Twilight

Sam Witwer

as Caius in Twilight

David Alpay

as Caius in Twilight

Scorpius Malfoy

as Caius in Twilight

Draco Malfoy

as Caius in Twilight

Gaspard Ulliel

as Caius in Twilight

Edmund Entin

as Alec in Twilight

Henry Cavill

as Alec in Twilight

Ty Simpkins

as Alec in Twilight

Christian Bale

as Alec in Twilight

Joaquin Phoenix

as Alec in Twilight

Michael Fassbender

as Alec in Twilight

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Alec in Twilight