Suggestions by @brayy

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Monsignor Timothy Howard in American Horror Story: Recast

Taylor Schilling

as Wendy Peyser in American Horror Story: Recast

Emmy Rossum

as Lana Winters in American Horror Story: Recast

Will Poulter

as Dr. Oliver Thredson in American Horror Story: Recast

mgk

as Leo Morrison in American Horror Story: Recast

Kevin Alves

as Kit Walker in American Horror Story: Recast

Amy Sedaris

as Marcy in American Horror Story: Recast

Matt Smith

as Charles Montgomery in American Horror Story: Recast

Hayley Atwell

as Billie Dean Howard in American Horror Story: Recast

Calista Flockhart

as Nora Montgomery in American Horror Story: Recast

Malina Weissman

as Leah in American Horror Story: Recast

Emma Mackey

as Hayden McClaine in American Horror Story: Recast

David Tennant

as Larry Harvey in American Horror Story: Recast

Lee Pace

as Patrick in American Horror Story: Recast

Conrad Ricamora

as Chad Warwick in American Horror Story: Recast

Lia McHugh

as Violet Harmon in American Horror Story: Recast

Madison Tevlin

as Adelaide Langdon in American Horror Story: Recast

Jack Champion

as Tate Langdon in American Horror Story: Recast

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Vivien Harmon in American Horror Story: Recast

Milo Ventimiglia

as Ben Harmon in American Horror Story: Recast