Suggestions by @bowiesbestie

David Bowie

as Gumby in The Adventures of Gumby

Timothée Chalamet

as String Cheese in If Foods Were People

Kate Moennig

as Dulce de Leche ice cream in If Foods Were People

Kate Moennig

as Rose in The Vampire Diaries

Jamie Clayton

as Lexi in The Vampire Diaries

Colton Haynes

as Tyler in The Vampire Diaries

Kristen Stewart

as Vicki in The Vampire Diaries

Brandon Flynn

as Matt in The Vampire Diaries

Ashley Benson

as Caroline in The Vampire Diaries

Stephanie Allynne

as Jenna in The Vampire Diaries

Kate McKinnon

as Jenna in The Vampire Diaries

Tessa Thompson

as Bonnie in The Vampire Diaries

Austin P. McKenzie

as Jeremy in The Vampire Diaries

Kate Moennig

as Corky in Bound

Matt Bomer

as Damon in The Vampire Diaries

Cody Fern

as Stefan in The Vampire Diaries

Arienne Mandi

as Elena in The Vampire Diaries

Robert Gant

as Superman in DCEU Rebooted

Jennifer Beals

as Wonder Woman in DCEU Rebooted

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Mayonnaise in If Foods Were People