Suggestions by @bosuthebluehedgehog

Channing Tatum

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Max Mittelman

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Jack Quaid

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Jason J. Lewis

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Jerry O'Connell

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Travis Willingham

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Nolan North

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Tim Daly

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

George Newbern

as Superman (animation) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Mason Dye

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Kyle Allen

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Wolfgang Novogratz

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Paul Mescal

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Brendan Fraser

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Matt Bomer

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Tyler Hoechlin

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Tom Welling

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Henry Cavill

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman

Brandon Routh

as Superman (live-action) in Casting a random character every saturday #22: Superman