Suggestions by @boomstick2000

Giovanni Ribisi

as Holiday Killer in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Spoiler

as Holiday Killer in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Tyler Mane

as Solomon Grundy in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Rhys Ifans

as Mad Hatter in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Adrien Brody

as Scarecrow in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Jennifer Connelly

as Poison Ivy in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Dennis Farina

as Carmine Falcone in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Ian McKellen

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Chris Cooper

as James Gordon in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Edward Norton

as Riddler in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Benicio del Toro

as The Joker in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Angelina Jolie

as Sofia Falcone in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Thandiwe Newton

as Catwoman in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Winona Ryder

as Gilda Dent in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Justin Theroux

as Harvey Dent in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Philip Seymour Hoffman

as Calendar Man in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Giovanni Ribisi

as Alberto Falcone in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Colin Farrell

as Batman in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Elliot Goldenthal

as Composer in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)

Akiva Goldsman

as Writer in Batman : Long Halloween (2004)