Suggestions by @bluejoy69

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Pat in Green Room (2005)

Peter Boyle

as Oswald "Oz" Cobblepot in The Batman (1972)

Shawn Hatosy

as Reece in Green Room (2005)

Paul Rudd

as Baron "Bear" Bailey in Obsession (1996)

Joey Lauren Adams

as Nikki Freeman in Obsession (1996)

Ed Harris

as Terence Fletcher in Whiplash (2004)

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Andrew Neiman in Whiplash (2004)

Constance Wu

as Emily Davis in Until Dawn (2006)

Milo Ventimiglia

as Josh Washington in Until Dawn (2006)

Alexis Bledel

as Ashley Brown in Until Dawn (2006)

Ryan Merriman

as Chris Hartley in Until Dawn (2006)

Robert Ri'chard

as Matt Taylor in Until Dawn (2006)

Chad Michael Murray

as Mike Munroe in Until Dawn (2006)

Maggie Grace

as Sam Giddings in Until Dawn (2006)

Brittany Snow

as Jessica Riley in Until Dawn (2006)

Christine Taylor

as Sam Giddings in Until Dawn (1996)

Rebecca Gayheart

as Jessica Riley in Until Dawn (1996)

Alyson Hannigan

as Ashley Brown in Until Dawn (1996)

Michael Rosenbaum

as Chris Hartley in Until Dawn (1996)

Larenz Tate

as Matt Taylor in Until Dawn (1996)