Suggestions by @blackvoid
11,273 suggestions
Willa Fitzgerald
as Poison Ivy in Richman’s: Poison Ivy (Horror)
Peter Schoelier
as The Rake in Creepypasta Casting Call
Johnny Depp
as Laughing Jack in Creepypasta Casting Call
Matthew Patrick Davis
as The Rake in Creepypasta Casting Call
Willem Dafoe
as Laughing Jack in Creepypasta Casting Call
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Slenderman in Creepypasta Casting Call
Dustin Ceithamer
as Slenderman in Creepypasta Casting Call
Sun Mingming
as Slenderman in Creepypasta Casting Call
Matthew Patrick Davis
as Slenderman in Creepypasta Casting Call
Robert Bobroczkyi
as Slenderman in Creepypasta Casting Call
Alisha Weir
as Jane the Killer in Creepypasta Casting Call
Spider-Man 3
as Influences in Richman’s: Hulk (Horror)
Aaron Taylor-Johnson
as Dr. Leonard “Doc” Samson in Richman’s: Hulk (Horror)
Paul Rust
as Dr. Samuel Sterns in Richman’s: Hulk (Horror)
Clancy Brown
as Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross in Richman’s: Hulk (Horror)
Nicholas Hoult
as The Hulk in Richman’s: Hulk (Horror)
Naomie Harris
as Carvey in Richman’s: The Outlast Theater (2026)
Carol Kane
as Veronica Osterfield in Richman’s: The Outlast Theater (2026)
Alfre Woodard
as Veronica Osterfield in Richman’s: The Outlast Theater (2026)
Brie Larson
as Veronica Osterfield in Richman’s: The Outlast Theater (2026)