Suggestions by @beleg
10 suggestions
Jim Caviezel
as Cirdan in The Silmarillion
+14-1Score: +13
Nicholas Hoult
as Beleg in The Silmarillion
+8-2Score: +6
Olivia Wilde
as Luthien in The Silmarillion
+9-21Score: -12
Wes Bentley
as Feanor in The Silmarillion
+7-15Score: -8
Christian Bale
as Fingolfin in The Silmarillion
+5-6Score: -1
Chris Pine
as Beren in The Silmarillion
+10-15Score: -5
James McAvoy
as Finrod in The Silmarillion
+4-5Score: -1
Alexander Skarsgård
as Tuor in The Silmarillion
+10-4Score: +6
Joe Manganiello
as Turin in The Silmarillion
+3-12Score: -9
Gary Oldman
as Sauron in The Silmarillion
+4-14Score: -10