Suggestions by @aquarius2099
4,831 suggestions
Oliver Jackson-Cohen
as Lucifer Morningstar in Lucifer
Octavia Spencer
as Annie Wilkes in Horror Legends
Yahya Abdul-Mateen II
as Candyman in Horror Legends
Tobin Bell
as Jigsaw in Horror Legends
Tony Todd
as Candyman in Horror Legends
Jennifer Tilly
as Tiffany in Horror Legends
Brad Dourif
as Chucky in Horror Legends
James Jude Courtney
as Michael Myers in Horror Legends
Joaquin Phoenix
as Jack Torrance in Horror Legends
Bonnie Aarons
as The Nun in Horror Legends
Derek Mears
as Jason Voorhees in Horror Legends
Evan Peters
as Jeffrey Dahmer in Horror Legends
Robert Englund
as Freddy Kreuger in Horror Legends
Roger L. Jackson
as Ghostface in Horror Legends
Robert Pattinson
as Patrick Bateman in Horror Legends
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Carrie White in Horror Legends
Jamie Lee Curtis
as Laurie Strode in Horror Legends
Penn Badgley
as Joe Goldberg in Horror Legends
Bruce Campbell
as Ash Williams in Horror Legends
Andrew Garfield
as Norman Bates in Horror Legends