Suggestions by @amyd723
2,384 suggestions
John C. Reilly
as O'Malley in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)
Brandon Routh
as Philo Barnum in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)
Lucas Jade Zumann
as Alonzo Mann in Parade
Darby Camp
as Mary Phagan in Parade
Gina Rodriguez
as Rosie in La Bamba (On Broadway)
Michael Rainey Jr.
as Understudy for Duke in Leave it on the Floor (Broadway)
Coy Stewart
as Understudy for Eppie in Leave it on the Floor (Broadway)
Nik Alexander
as Understudy for Princess in Leave it on the Floor (Broadway)
Lili Taylor
as Sister Helen Prejean in Dead Man Walking
Raúl Esparza
as P.T. Barnum in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)
Jeremy Jordan
as Phillip Carlyle in The Greatest Showman (Broadway)
Bridgit Mendler
as Understudy for Marion in Grace of My Heart (Broadway)
Bryan Terrell Clark
as Understudy for Stylettes in Grace of My Heart (Broadway)
Joshua Henry
as Eugene in Grace of My Heart (Broadway)
Dyllón Burnside
as Curtis in Grace of My Heart (Broadway)
Diego Boneta
as Understudy for Ritchie in La Bamba (On Broadway)
Alberto Rosende
as Ritchie Valens in La Bamba (On Broadway)
Latrice Royale
as Understudy for Christina in Leave it on the Floor (Broadway)
Bob the Drag Queen
as Christina Allure in Leave it on the Floor (Broadway)
Sal Landi
as Understudy for Enrique in Zoot Suit