Suggestions by @aluminumforest

Michael Jai White

as John Diggle (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Jennifer Hale

as Felicity Smoak (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Woody Harrelson

as Deadshot (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Clancy Brown

as Carmine Falcone (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Diego Tinoco

as Blue Beetle (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Ben Pronsky

as Blue Beetle Scarab (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Brian T. Delaney

as Ted Kord (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Jason Isaacs

as Merlyn (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Jennifer Hale

as Roxy Rocket (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Michael Aaron

as James Gordon (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Devin Ratray

as Harvey Bullock (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Josh Lucas

as Rick Flag (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Josh Lawson

as Captain Boomerang (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Andy Serkis

as Praying Mantis-Man (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Giancarlo Esposito

as Komodo (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Matt Smith

as Dr. Death (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Kiff VandenHeuvel

as Mr. Freeze (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Mechad Brooks

as Black Tarantula (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Steve Blum

as King Shark (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)

Robin Givens

as Amanda Waller (episode 9) in Tales From The Dark Multiverse (season 1)