Suggestions by @alanstudios

Freddie Highmore

as Michael Sinterniklaas in Nintendo

Jack Black

as James Carter Cathcart in Nintendo

Emile Hirsch

as James Carter Cathcart in Nintendo

Sam Lerner

as Eric Stuart in Nintendo

Rheagan Wallace

as Veronica Taylor in Nintendo

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Jay Ward in Nintendo

Kyle Hebert

as Jay Ward in Nintendo

Johnny Galecki

as Mike West in Nintendo

Doug Brochu

as Ted Lewis in Nintendo

Colleen O'Shaughnessey

as Amy Birnbaum in Nintendo

Amanda Bynes

as Caety Sagoian in Nintendo

Veronica Dunne

as Laura Faye Smith in Nintendo

Sharon Lawrence

as Lani Minella in Nintendo

FAKE

as Deanna Mustard in Nintendo

Scarlett Johansson

as Jen Taylor in Nintendo

Jennifer Garner

as Jen Taylor in Nintendo

Kali Rocha

as Samantha Kelly in Nintendo

Iggy Pop

as Kenny James in Nintendo

Lauren Taylor

as Jen Taylor in Nintendo

Mara Wilson

as Jen Taylor in Nintendo