Suggestions by @alamosimpson

Jon Lovitz

as Adolf Hitler in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x2-The Man in the Bottle

Ben Stiller

as IRS agent in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x2-The Man in the Bottle

Jan Hooks

as Edna Castle in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x2-The Man in the Bottle

Jon Lovitz

as Arthur Castle in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x2-The Man in the Bottle

Matthew Broderick

as Major William Gart in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Josh Taylor

as Medical officer in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Ally Sheedy

as Nurse in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Pamela Reed

as Amy in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Bartender in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Lisa Kudrow

as Blond Nurse in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Michael J. Fox

as Major William Gart in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x11 And When the Sky Was Opened

Kate Beckinsale

as Susanna Kittridge in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x24 Long Live Walter Jameson

Michael Gough

as Prof. Samuel Kittridge in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x24 Long Live Walter Jameson

George Clooney

as Walter Jameson in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x24 Long Live Walter Jameson

Richard Attenborough

as Mr. Pip in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x28 A Nice Place to Visit

Joe Pesci

as Henry Francis Valentine in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x28 A Nice Place to Visit

Chris Carter

as Director in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x28 - Will the Real Martian Please Stand Up?

Leslie Nielsen

as Haley, the cook in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x28 - Will the Real Martian Please Stand Up?

Tony Sirico

as Ramon in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x013 The Four of Us Are Dying

Lisa Whelchel

as Maggie in The Twilight Zone (1990s)/1x013 The Four of Us Are Dying