Suggestions by @alamosimpson

Ed O'Neill

as Policeman in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 1x33 - Mr. Bevis

Neil McDonough

as Policeman writing ticket in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 1x33 - Mr. Bevis

Steven Spielberg

as Producer in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

David Fincher

as Director in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Nicole Kidman

as Receptionist in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Lenny Von Dohlen

as Mr. Vance in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Heather Graham

as Receptionist in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Bob Hoskins

as Farraday in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Kin Shriner

as Surgeon in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Len Lesser

as Gambler #2 in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Ed Lauter

as Gambler #1 in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Mel Gibson

as Young John Holt in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Brad Pitt

as Young John Holt in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Tom Cruise

as Young John Holt in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x31 - The Trade-Ins

Hank Azaria

as LaGuardia Air Traffic Controller (1939) in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x18 - The Odyssey of Flight 33

William Petersen

as Passenger #3 in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x18 - The Odyssey of Flight 33

Robert Zemeckis

as Director in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x18 - The Odyssey of Flight 33

Steven Spielberg

as Producer in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 2x18 - The Odyssey of Flight 33

Vincent D'Onofrio

as The Intruder in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x10 -The Midnight Sun

William Petersen

as Doctor in The Twilight Zone (1990s) 3x10 -The Midnight Sun