Suggestions by @adrianpintado

Leopold Strauss

as James Woods in What if this actor played

Joaquín Cosío

as Capitán Espinoza in Red Dead Redemption (2020's)

Angelo Bronte (Red Dead 2)

as Al Pacino in What if this actor played

Vincente De Santa (Red Dead)

as Al Pacino in What if this actor played

Sam Trapani (Mafia)

as Al Pacino in What if this actor played

Flaco Hernández (Red Dead)

as Joaquín Cosío in What if this actor played

Joaquín Cosío

as Flaco Hernández in Red Dead Redemption (2020's)

Frank Nitti

as Adam Driver in What if this actor played

Prof. Henry Jones (Indiana Jones)

as Bernard Hill in What if this actor played

Henry Jones Sr.

as Bernard Hill in What if this actor played

Micah Bell

as Sean Bean in What if this actor played

Luisa Fortuna (Red Dead)

as Salma Hayek in What if this actor played

Andrew Milton

as Christopher Plummer in What if this actor played

Inspector Clouseau

as Sacha Baron Cohen in What if this actor played

Leviticus Cornwall (Red Dead 2)

as Kelsey Grammer in What if this actor played

Andrew Milton

as Peter Cushing in What if this actor played

Father Cesare Ventura

as Peter Cushing in What if this actor played

Magua (The Last Of The Mohicans)

as Graham Greene in What if this actor played

Maximus Decimus Meridius

as Gerard Butler in What if this actor played

Micah Bell

as Antony Starr in What if this actor played