Suggestions by @adrianpintado

Denzel Washington

as Sheriff Sam Freeman in Red Dead Redemption 2

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Black Belle in Red Dead Redemption 2

James McAvoy

as Brother Dorkins in Red Dead Redemption 2

Donal Logue

as Billy Midnight in Red Dead Redemption 2

Álvaro Rico

as Archie Downes in Red Dead Redemption 2

Olivier Richters

as Tommy in Red Dead Redemption 2

Chris Pine

as 2010's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Rodrigo Santoro

as Abraham Reyes in Red Dead Redemption (2000's-2010's)

Wagner Moura

as Colonel Fussar in Red Dead Redemption 2: The Movie

Wagner Moura

as Colonel Alberto Fussar in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Wagner Moura

as Coronel Alberto Fussar in Red Dead Redemption (2020's)

Robert Redford

as 1960's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Austin Butler

as 2020's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Chris Evans

as 2010's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Bradley Cooper

as 2000's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Brad Pitt

as 1990's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Michael Keaton

as 1980's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Harrison Ford

as 1970's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Steve McQueen

as 1960's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades

Paul Newman

as 1950's in Actors who could play Eliot Ness in various different decades