Suggestions by @adrianpintado

Pintel (Pirates of the Caribbean)

as 2003 in The Best Villains of the Years

Guy of Gisbourne

as 1991 in The Best Villains of the Years

Maid Marian (Prince of Thieves)

as 1991 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Will Scarlet

as 1991 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Joshamee Gibbs

as 2003 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Elena Montero De La Vega

as 1998 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Ambrose Peabody

as Paul Newman in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Azeem (Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves)

as James Earl Joans in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Ambrose Peabody

as 1991 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Azeem (Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves)

as 1991 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Elena de la Vega

as 1998 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Ardeth Bay

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Jonathan Carnahan

as The Mummy in Vote for your fave Fictionals Characters

Jonathan Carnahan

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Evelyn O'Connell

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Katrina Van Tassel (1999 film)

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Evelyn Carnahan

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Ichabod Crane (1999 film)

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Rick O'Connell

as 1999 in The Best Heroes of the Years

Anck-Su-Namun

as 1999 in The Best Villains of the Years