Suggestions by @adamatc

Peter Sarsgaard

as Peter in Another Round (American Remake)

Mark Ruffalo

as Tommy in Another Round (American Remake)

Donald Sutherland

as Caleb Smith in Ex Machina (1975)

Alan Arkin

as Nathan Bateman in Ex Machina (1975)

Kirsten Dunst

as Kay Adams-Corleone in The Godfather: Parts I and II (2012 - 2014)

Kirsten Dunst

as Kay Adams in The Godfather Duology (2012-2014)

Kirsten Dunst

as Kay Adams in The Godfather remake

Jennifer Beals

as Catwomen in The Batman (1997)

David Fincher

as Director in The Batman (1997)

Sean Penn

as The Penguin in The Batman (1997)

Edward Norton

as The Riddler in The Batman (1997)

Thandie Newton

as Catwomen in The Batman (1997)

Billy Crudup

as Batman in The Batman (1997)

Julie Newmar

as Corey Ellman in Good Time (1977)

David Proval

as Ray in Good Time (1977)

Lily James

as Skylar in Good Will Hunting (2017)

Damian Lewis

as Professor Gerard Lambeau in Good Will Hunting (2017)

Paul Rudd

as Sean Maguire in Good Will Hunting (2017)

Samuel L. Jackson

as Ned Logan in Unforgiven (2012)

Woody Harrelson

as Little Bill Daggett in Unforgiven (2012)