Suggestions by @accaffrey
2,917 suggestions

Brett Gelman
as James A. Garfield in Presidential
Michael Gross
as Rutherford B. Hayes in Presidential

Russell Crowe
as Ulysses S. Grant in Presidential

Dean Norris
as Andrew Johnson in Presidential

Liam Neeson
as Abraham Lincoln in Presidential
Anthony Hopkins
as James Buchanan in Presidential

Tom Hiddleston
as Franklin Pierce in Presidential

Alec Baldwin
as Millard Fillmore in Presidential

Asher Bishop
as Skippy in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Bradley Cooper
as Alan-a-Dale in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Queen Latifah
as Lady Kluck in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Michael Douglas
as Friar Tuck in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)
Ian McDiarmid
as Sir Hiss in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Mark Hamill
as Sheriff of Nottingham in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Joaquin Phoenix
as Prince John in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

John C. Reilly
as Little John in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Hayley Atwell
as Maid Marian in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)

Taron Egerton
as Robin Hood in Robin Hood (Live-Action Remake)
Stellan Skarsgård
as Zachary Taylor in Presidential

Kevin Kline
as James K. Polk in Presidential