Suggestions by @ 2ktylorwilliams15

Elliot Page

as Arno Stark in Spider-Man 4

Malcolm Ray

as Hobbie Brown in Spider-Man 4

Doug Walker

as Hobbie Brown in Spider-Man 4

+0-1Score: -1

Sophia Lillis

as Mayday Parker in Spider-Man 4

Kristen Dunst

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 4

Tobey Maguire

as Peter Parker in Spider-Man 4

+4-0Score: +4

Dylan O'Brien

as Johnny Jameson in The Sinister 6 (The Amazing Spider-Man 6)

Campbell Scott

as Richard Parker in The Sinister 6 (The Amazing Spider-Man 6)

+5-0Score: +5

Ray Fisher

as Randy Robertson in The Sinister 6 (The Amazing Spider-Man 6)

Mila Kunis

as Silvija Sablinova in The Sinister 6 (The Amazing Spider-Man 6)

+3-3Score: 0

Jared Harris

as Otto Octavius/Doctor Octopus in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Felicity Jones

as Felicia Hardy in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

+3-0Score: +3

Ray Fisher

as Randy Robertson in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Dylan O'Brien

as Johnny Jameson in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Peyton List

as Sally Avril in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Rhys Ifans

as Curt Connors in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Jamie Foxx

as Max Dillion in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Olivia Holt

as Liz Allen in The Amazing Spider-Man 5

Michael Massee

as The Gentleman/Norman Osborn in The Amazing Spider-Man 5