Suggestions by @24601
2,495 suggestions
Josh Brolin
as Morgoth in Beren and Luthien
Jeremy Irons
as Barahir in Beren and Luthien
Matthew McConaughey
as Sauron in Beren and Luthien
Harry Lloyd
as Curufin in Beren and Luthien
Dan Stevens
as Celegorm in Beren and Luthien
Eddie Redmayne
as Celebrimbor in Beren and Luthien
Cate Blanchett
as Galadriel in Beren and Luthien
Jennifer Connelly
as Melian in Beren and Luthien
James D'Arcy
as Thingol in Beren and Luthien
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
as Finrod in Beren and Luthien
Saoirse Ronan
as Luthien in Beren and Luthien
Charlie Cox
as Beren in Beren and Luthien
Timothy Dalton
as Sador in Children of Hurin
Robin Lord Taylor
as Brandir in Children of Hurin
Gemma Arterton
as Aredhel in Children of Hurin
Joaquin Phoenix
as Eöl The Dark Elf in Children of Hurin
Jennifer Connelly
as Melian in Children of Hurin
Harry Lloyd
as Curufin in Children of Hurin
Dan Stevens
as Celegorm in Children of Hurin
Matt Bomer
as Maglor in Children of Hurin