![Totally Killer [2025] Fan Casting Poster](http://assets.mycast.io/posters/totally-killer-2025-fan-casting-poster-471364-medium.jpg?1716785137)
Fan CastingTotally Killer [2025]
by Jen D'Angelo, David Matalon & Sasha Perl-Rave
Story added by ramimalekeyes on May 27, 2024
The story follows Jamie who, after her mother is murdered by the same Sweet 16 Killer who went on a murder spree 35 years earlier, travels back in time to 1987, where she pairs up with her mother to catch the killer during his original spree and return to her timeline before she is trapped in the past forever.read more
read synopsis
Fan Casting Roles for Totally Killer [2025]
-
Jamie Hughes (Colette)
![Elsie Fisher as Jamie Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-elsie-fisher-35079_large.jpg?1580364867)
Top suggestion:
Elsie Fisher
Cast Your Vote -
Pam Hughes
![Alex Borstein as Pam Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-alex-borstein-17003_large.jpg?1578184067)
Top suggestion:
Alex Borstein
Cast Your Vote -
Young Pam
![Mikey Madison as Young Pam in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-mikey-madison-1084020_large.jpg?1716820176)
Top suggestion:
Mikey Madison
Cast Your Vote -
Blake Hughes
![Noah Emmerich as Blake Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-noah-emmerich-136825_large.jpg?1603150515)
Top suggestion:
Noah Emmerich
Cast Your Vote -
Young Blake
![Brandon Flynn as Young Blake in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-brandon-flynn-946389_large.jpg?1703126297)
Top suggestion:
Brandon Flynn
Cast Your Vote -
Amelia Creston
![Iman Benson as Amelia Creston in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-iman-benson-846760_large.jpg?1692634087)
Top suggestion:
Iman Benson
Cast Your Vote -
Lauren Creston
![Regina King as Lauren Creston in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-regina-king-452558_large.jpg?1654883973)
Top suggestion:
Regina King
Cast Your Vote -
Young Lauren
![Quei Tann as Young Lauren in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-quei-tann-1090934_large.jpg?1717597868)
Top suggestion:
Quei Tann
Cast Your Vote -
Chris Dubusage
![Christian Slater as Chris Dubusage in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-christian-slater-611492_large.jpg?1670017620)
Top suggestion:
Christian Slater
Cast Your Vote -
Young Chris
![Judah Lewis as Young Chris in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-judah-lewis-448296_large.jpg?1654461717)
Top suggestion:
Judah Lewis
Cast Your Vote -
Doug Summers
![Bokeem Woodbine as Doug Summers in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-bokeem-woodbine-237000_large.jpg?1625204674)
Top suggestion:
Bokeem Woodbine
Cast Your Vote -
Young Doug
![Jeremy Pope as Young Doug in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-jeremy-pope-100286_large.jpg?1591910177)
Top suggestion:
Jeremy Pope
Cast Your Vote -
Kara Lim
![Margaret Cho as Kara Lim in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-margaret-cho-243273_large.jpg?1626386038)
Top suggestion:
Margaret Cho
Cast Your Vote -
Young Kara
![HoYeon as Young Kara in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-hoyeon-jung-839415_large.jpg?1691884262)
Top suggestion:
HoYeon
Cast Your Vote -
Randy Finkle
![Cedric Yarbrough as Randy Finkle in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-cedric-yarbrough-986753_large.jpg?1707147241)
Top suggestion:
Cedric Yarbrough
Cast Your Vote -
Young Randy
![Miles Fowler as Young Randy in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-miles-fowler-978543_large.jpg?1706336024)
Top suggestion:
Miles Fowler
Cast Your Vote -
Marisa Song
![Liza Soberano as Marisa Song in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-liza-soberano-26684_large.jpg?1578918549)
Top suggestion:
Liza Soberano
Cast Your Vote -
Tiffany Clark
![Bebe Wood as Tiffany Clark in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-bebe-wood-954967_large.jpg?1703924180)
Top suggestion:
Bebe Wood
Cast Your Vote -
Heather Hernandez
![Indya Moore as Heather Hernandez in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-indya-moore-219667_large.jpg?1622114132)
Top suggestion:
Indya Moore
Cast Your Vote -
Dennis Lim
![Ken Jeong as Dennis Lim in Totally Killer [2025]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-ken-jeong-160533_large.jpg?1609661836)
Top suggestion:
Ken Jeong
Cast Your Vote
![Elsie Fisher as Jamie Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-elsie-fisher-35079_large.jpg?1580364867)
![Alex Borstein as Pam Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-alex-borstein-17003_large.jpg?1578184067)
![Mikey Madison as Young Pam in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-mikey-madison-1084020_large.jpg?1716820176)
![Noah Emmerich as Blake Hughes in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-noah-emmerich-136825_large.jpg?1603150515)
![Brandon Flynn as Young Blake in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-brandon-flynn-946389_large.jpg?1703126297)
![Iman Benson as Amelia Creston in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-iman-benson-846760_large.jpg?1692634087)
![Regina King as Lauren Creston in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-regina-king-452558_large.jpg?1654883973)
![Quei Tann as Young Lauren in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-quei-tann-1090934_large.jpg?1717597868)
![Christian Slater as Chris Dubusage in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-christian-slater-611492_large.jpg?1670017620)
![Judah Lewis as Young Chris in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-judah-lewis-448296_large.jpg?1654461717)
![Bokeem Woodbine as Doug Summers in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-bokeem-woodbine-237000_large.jpg?1625204674)
![Jeremy Pope as Young Doug in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-jeremy-pope-100286_large.jpg?1591910177)
![Margaret Cho as Kara Lim in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-margaret-cho-243273_large.jpg?1626386038)
![HoYeon as Young Kara in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-hoyeon-jung-839415_large.jpg?1691884262)
![Cedric Yarbrough as Randy Finkle in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-cedric-yarbrough-986753_large.jpg?1707147241)
![Miles Fowler as Young Randy in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-miles-fowler-978543_large.jpg?1706336024)
![Liza Soberano as Marisa Song in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-liza-soberano-26684_large.jpg?1578918549)
![Bebe Wood as Tiffany Clark in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-bebe-wood-954967_large.jpg?1703924180)
![Indya Moore as Heather Hernandez in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-indya-moore-219667_large.jpg?1622114132)
![Ken Jeong as Dennis Lim in Totally Killer [2025]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-ken-jeong-160533_large.jpg?1609661836)
This story does not allow roles to be added.
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Need an account?
Create a free account
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Join the Conversation
0 comments on this story
Leave a Comment