Fan Casting K.J. Apa as Toby Flenderson in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

daviddyster made this fan casting suggestion on July 11, 2024. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

K.J. Apa as Toby Flenderson in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

K.J. ApaNew Zealand

27 years old
Keneti James Fitzgerald Apa (born 17 June 1997) is a New Zealand actor, singer, and musician. He began acting playing Kane Jenkins in the New Zealand primetime soap opera Shortland Street from 2013...
See Profile
The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

I'm Not Superstitious, I'm Just a Little-Stitious
by NBC, Greg Daniels, and me
An origin story for Michael Scott's time at Dunder Mifflin before the events of The Office, starting with his time as salesman in the early 1990s, before eventually becoming manager. Narrated by th...
See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on K.J. Apa as Toby Flenderson in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

K.J. Apa is known for his roles in The Hate U Give, The Last Summer, and A Dog's Purpose. He has been suggested by fans for 5,640 roles on myCast, including Wally West in The Perfect Justice League Movie. Similar actors include Tom Holland, Dacre Montgomery, and Cameron Monaghan. K.J. Apa was suggested to play Toby Flenderson in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025) by daviddyster. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Robert Pattinson, Dylan Minnette, and Nick Robinson. The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025) has 9 roles, including Michael Scott, William Schneider, and Stanley Hudson.

Supporters (1)
Opposers (1)

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Toby Flenderson in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)