Fan Casting "Secret Relationship" in Superhuman (Season Five)

In a quietly devastating revelation, it’s revealed that Erin Walters and Kate Rooney had been secretly dating during Jacob and Kate’s relationship. Jacob, now finding, doesn't really care much. After Ricky’s death, Kate breaks up with both Jacob and Erin — hurt not just by what happened, but by the web of half-truths and silence that led there. While she’s more heartbroken than angry at Erin, she still ends the relationship, needing space and healing.