Fan Casting Nate Macauley in One of Us Is Lying

The “criminal” of the Bayview Four, Nate is a burnout, womanizer, and drug dealer who has earned a bad reputation for himself over the years. Nate is on probation for dealing marijuana, and rumors started on the About This blog suggest that Nate hasn’t learned from his past mistakes. Though Nate seems like a stereotypical druggie, it’s eventually revealed that he only turned to his illicit trade out of necessity; his mother abandoned him and his low-functioning alcoholic father years ago, and Nate has been left to pick up the pieces of his family’s shattered life. Nate’s emotional world is fraught, but he is a loving pet owner and a dedicated movie buff.