Fan Casting Alyson Hannigan as American Pie in Hottest Actress by Franchise

More Fan Casting Suggestions for American Pie in Hottest Actress by Franchise

• 

  Shannon Elizabeth

  Shannon Elizabeth

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  23 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  January Jones

  January Jones

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  19 Vote Yes

  3 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Tara Reid

  Tara Reid

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  17 Vote Yes

  3 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Mena Suvari

  Mena Suvari

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  14 Vote Yes

  3 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Ali Cobrin

  Ali Cobrin

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  13 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Katrina Bowden

  Katrina Bowden

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  10 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Madison Pettis

  Madison Pettis

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  7 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  American Pie

• 

  Natasha Lyonne

  Natasha Lyonne

  as

  American Pie

  in

  Hottest Actress by Franchise

  10 Vote Yes

  6 Vote No

  

  American Pie