Casting Suggestions by el_indio

• 

  Mark Wahlberg

  Mark Wahlberg

  as

  Archer Fordham

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  13 Vote Yes

  5 Vote No

  

  Archer Fordham

• 

  Michael Caine

  Michael Caine

  as

  Colonel Henry Favours

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  12 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Colonel Henry Favours

• 

  Aidan Turner

  Aidan Turner

  as

  Gerald Braithwaite

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  8 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Gerald Braithwaite

• 

  Mark Ruffalo

  Mark Ruffalo

  as

  Reverend Orville Swanson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  9 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Reverend Orville Swanson

• 

  Mark Ruffalo

  Mark Ruffalo

  as

  Josiah Trelawny

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  11 Vote Yes

  9 Vote No

  

  Josiah Trelawny

• 

  Ian McShane

  Ian McShane

  as

  Tavish Gray

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  13 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Tavish Gray

• 

  Timothy Dalton

  Timothy Dalton

  as

  Tavish Gray

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  17 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Tavish Gray

• 

  Graham Greene

  Graham Greene

  as

  Rains Falls

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  8 Vote Yes

  7 Vote No

  

  Rains Falls

• 

  Michael Greyeyes

  Michael Greyeyes

  as

  Rains Falls

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  12 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Rains Falls

• 

  David Midthunder

  David Midthunder

  as

  Rains Falls

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  11 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Rains Falls

• 

  Eddie Redmayne

  Eddie Redmayne

  as

  Cleet

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  14 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Cleet

• 

  Joseph Gordon-Levitt

  Joseph Gordon-Levitt

  as

  Cleet

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  7 Vote Yes

  8 Vote No

  

  Cleet

• 

  Jack Nicholson

  Jack Nicholson

  as

  Leviticus Cornwall

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  23 Vote Yes

  3 Vote No

  

  Leviticus Cornwall

• 

  Brad Pitt

  Brad Pitt

  as

  Colm O'Driscoll

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  22 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Colm O'Driscoll

• 

  Hayley Atwell

  Hayley Atwell

  as

  Mary Linton

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  23 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Mary Linton

• 

  Mauricio Ochmann

  Mauricio Ochmann

  as

  Javier Escuella

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  11 Vote Yes

  11 Vote No

  

  Javier Escuella